Monday, May 01, 2006
Inclusive Country, Exclusive Parliament

That was one of the many slogans bandied around at the Workers' Party rally tonight, at Hougang Avenue 4 that drew cheers and whoops of agreement from the crowd.  Thousands strong, they thronged the open field, pouring onto any empty space of green, crowding round a blaring loudspeaker for want of an available view of the real stars of the night -- the speakers, which included Sylvia Lim, Low Thia Kang, Goh Meng Seng and Perry Tong.  It was a heartening feeling, standing under the night sky, breathing in a neighbour's cigarette smoke, watching the aunties squat and the ah peks spit and the couples cuddle, the disembodied voice coming from the loudspeaker illiciting loud cries of 'Wor--ker's Party!' -- turning my head to watch the stunning sight of the flats nearby crowded with spectators on every stairway, watching from every landing, peering out through the window grills.  So very many people! The smoke still soaks my clothes, my ears still ring, and on the back of my eyelids I can still see so vividly, the sheer number of people, and how loudly I could hear them shout from afar.

The Workers' Party did not disappoint like the SDP did at their rally.  They brought up some sound proposals in addition to their rhetoric, though the crowd stayed mostly silent to economic jargon, most of which came from Perry Tong.  But the jargon was balanced, in his case, with simple and communicative language, and phrases of Hokkien which drew appreciative whistles and laughs from the crowd.  Among his proposals were for the Singaporean government to ask for steep discounts in patent royalties with the biomedical research firms they negotiate with, or for the right of Singaporean companies to manufacture generic drugs locally.  He spoke of his desire to make Singapore into a hub for the manufacturing and distribution of medicine, which would dramatically decrease shipping costs, translating into cheaper healthcare and increased jobs and investments.  He also suggested that patients with chronic illnesses like kidney failure should only be charged cost-price in their treatment.  The biggest cheers came from the crowd when he raised the issue of his desire to see the removal of GST for healthcare.

Most of the speeches were delievered in dialect, which I unfortunately don't understand, but I caught the Mandarin bits.  Essentially the party focussed on two issues: healthcare, and upgrading.  Sylvia Lim and Low Thia Kang, in their speeches, besides railing against the PAP for being unfair and divisive in their upgrading policies, also attacked the idea of means-testing, questioning the ability for a fair yardstick by which one may measure wealth to be implemented.  If one measured wealth by household income, for instance, it might not take into consideration the number of people in the family.  If it measured wealth by accommodation, it would hardly be representative.  If it measured wealth by an  individual's income, that would not take into account his debts, his elderly parents to support, etc., and in any case, richer people pay more taxes under the current progressive system already.  So everyone should have sovereignty over their remaining money, to spend it how they like, and to plan for their own futures.

Mohammed Rahizan Yaacob's airtime was the most entertaining to me, partly because it was one out of only two English speeches I remember, and partly because of its inventiveness.  He began sombrely with "Friends, I have a grave announcement...yesterday I lost my umbrella.  There were so many things to do that I forgot where I had put it." I think the irony was lost a little on the crowd, because he was not totally clear, but I appreciated his sarcasm regarding how the PAP was making a big deal out of a simple mistake.  He also ridiculed the PAP for saying how Rahizan would not be able to raise the education of Malays, as opposed to Dr. Yaacob Ibrahim, by saying: "Yaacob Ibrahim is the Minister of what? Water.  Why is he asking the Minister of Water to settle this? I thought we were a multi-racial society.  We should be asking Tharman Shanmugaratnam to raise the educational levels of Malay and non-Malay pupils.  He is the Minister of Education."

I wonder how much of this the Straits Times will cover tomorrow.  I doubt very much that they'll cover the portion of Rahizan Yaacob's speech which called for transparency and accountability on the part of the government through allowing for a free and independent media, uninterfered with by the government.  Nope, the Straits Times is certainly avoiding that issue.  Publishing it would be a bit too meta-journalistic!

Posted at 02:29 am by gaylegoh

Sad Sad Man
May 3, 2006   11:22 PM PDT
 
I have been deprived of the right to excercise my choice and the best I can do is show my support at the rallies..the scenes repeat themselves..1997, 2001..will the crowd excercise their rights or simply accept hegemony..like always. Do tell my friends
zyn
May 1, 2006   02:07 PM PDT
 
hey i was there too! it was brilliant! never seen so many singaporeans crowded at one place without there being any freebies. :)
 

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments







Previous Entry Home Next Entry
gayle goh

<< May 2006 >>
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 01 02 03 04 05 06
07 08 09 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31

profile

Recommended Posts

Do We Owe Our Existence to the PAP?
A Message From a Media Insider
The Bilahari Kausikan Post
Bilahari Kausikan's Reply
Money in Politics, Politics in Money
Workers' Party, PAP or My Living Room Armchair?
My Vision for Singapore
Democracy is Dangerous!
Singapore's Midlife Crisis
Smile, Singapore! WB and IMF Meetings a Scam
Chees' Rally & March; Interview with Gandhi Ambalam

worthy reads
xenoboy sg
students' sketchpad
singabloodypore
singapore mind
young republic
i-do-not-speak


friends
kwee boon
brendan
ben teh
2sa3
gecko

shameless advertising
if you're looking for air compressors and ancillary parts (vane, rotary, screw, etc), my dad sells them! ;)



disclaimer
the author of this site has based all her personal opinions on what is known to her as fact. any error is made of ignorance, not malice, and is accordingly apologized for. any views and opinions expressed by other persons on this site are not the responsibility of the author, nor does she claim to espouse them.

If you want to be updated on this weblog Enter your email here:




rss feed